Food Safety vs Customs: Supreme Court to Decide Who Can Test Imported Food

 The Supreme Court has agreed to decide an important question for food importers: when imported food arrives at an Indian port, which law governs how it is sampled and tested, the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 or the Customs Act, 1962?

A bench of Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar issued notice on a special leave petition challenging a Calcutta High Court ruling. The bench called the matter an issue of “considerable significance.” The question is whether Sections 25 and 47 of the FSS Act, which govern imported food and its sampling, override Sections 110 and 144 of the Customs Act, which empower Customs officers to seize goods and draw samples. The court noted that the goods in question are areca nuts, a perishable commodity. Senior Advocate Siddharth Dave appeared for the petitioner.

The case concerns three containers of areca nuts, weighing 84.48 metric tonnes, imported from Belawan Port in Indonesia. The importer filed a Bill of Entry at the Inland Container Depot in Durgapur, declaring the cargo as roasted areca nuts with an assessable value of about ₹1.12 crore.

Acting on specific intelligence, the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence’s Kolkata unit suspected the cargo was actually dried areca nuts, a prohibited category. It believed the goods had been misdeclared to get around the DGFT’s minimum import price and CBIC tariff values. The DRI put the consignment on hold and stopped it from being routed to the Food Import Clearance System, through which FSSAI handles imported food.

Customs drew samples under Section 144 of the Customs Act and sent them to the National Food Laboratory in Kolkata. The laboratory found the nuts unsafe under the FSS Act, citing mould, insect infestation and high levels of aflatoxin. Customs then seized the containers. At the importer’s request, the samples were retested at the Central Revenues Control Laboratory in New Delhi, which confirmed that the cargo was misdeclared and unfit for human consumption.

The importer challenged the sampling and seizure in the High Court. It argued that only FSSAI-authorised officers could draw samples of imported food under Section 47(5) of the FSS Act. A single judge agreed, declared the Customs sampling illegal, set aside both laboratory reports and ordered fresh sampling.

On appeal by the DRI and the Commissioner of Customs (Preventive), Kolkata, a Division Bench overturned that decision. It held that Customs’ sampling power under Section 144 is broad and does not stop applying just because the goods are food. Customs must first establish what an imported product actually is and how it should be classified for tariff purposes, the bench said, while FSSAI’s role is limited to certifying whether the food is safe to eat. Food safety law, it held, cannot be used to block Customs investigations into misclassification and fiscal fraud.

The Division Bench also said the FSS Act overrides other laws only where there is a direct conflict over food safety standards. FSSAI’s own sampling process under the 2017 import regulations begins only after a Bill of Entry reaches the Food Import Clearance System, it said, and executive instructions cannot limit Customs’ statutory powers. It cancelled the single judge’s directions on fresh sampling, release of the cargo and demurrage waivers. It ruled that any objections to the sampling and test reports should be raised in the show cause notice proceedings under the Customs Act, and told Customs to proceed with them.

The Supreme Court’s ruling will settle how far Customs and FSSAI can each go in handling imported food, an issue that affects importers, regulators and port authorities across the country.